Scoring Guidelines

Scoring Guidelines

NO THANKS  0-49Will not drink.
DESPERATION  50-59Will drink in desperation if there is nothing else to drink.
OKAY  60-69Will drink again; it's an okay tipple.
GOOD  70-79Will enjoy drinking again; at the high end they are very good.
GREAT  80-89Will drink with great pleasure.
WOW  90-99Will savour every drop.
I POUR IT, I SCORE IT, I STORE IT
Kilchoman 2011 5 Year Old KWM

Kilchoman 2011 5 Year Old KWM, 56.2% abv

Butterscotch, peat, mild citrus and sherry on the nose. Spices, tangy salted caramel, mild peat, barley and fruit on the palate. Chewy. Light tangy finish.

88
Kilchoman 2011 KWM

Kilchoman 2011 KWM, 57.5% abv

Rich, light smoke, fruit, vanilla then sour cherries on the nose. Creamy, wee salt, vanilla and oak on the palate. Wee tang on the finish

87
Glenfarclas 25 Year Old KWM

Glenfarclas 25 Year Old KWM, 52% abv

Vanilla, fruit compote, mild pineapple, fruit on the nose. Smooth tropical fruit, sweet, fruity leather, tangy vanilla on the palate. Long dry finish.

87
Glenfarclas 25 years old

Glenfarclas 25 years old, 43% abv

Sherry, creamy fruit flan, cherry, truffles and spice on the nose. Big mouthfeel, sweet brown sugar, fruit, dry, tannic with leather on the palate. Long finish.

86

View all scores >